Import low energy distribution (issue on longitudinal plane)

https://www.dacm-logiciels.fr/plotwin
Post Reply
FranceFred Bouly
Beginner
Beginner
Posts: 5
Joined: Tue 16 Feb 2021 13:55
Country:
France (fr)
France

Import low energy distribution (issue on longitudinal plane)

Post by FranceFred Bouly »

Hi,

I am trying to import, from an ASCII file, an electron beam distribution, with a low kinetic energy (2.65043 keV) and a large energy spread.

once .dst file generated by Plotwin, transverse plane is ok, see attached image.

While on the longitudinal plane the distribution seems to be "distorted", see attached image . \delta coordinates seem to be ok, but not in Z?

when importing other distribution at higher energies > 100 keV, I do not have the problem anymore.

I also attach the ASCII distribution file.

Could you help me with that?

cheers
Attachments
distrib.txt
(405.99 KiB) Downloaded 1693 times
XXp.png
XXp.png (1.47 MiB) Viewed 36249 times
deltaZ.png
deltaZ.png (611.58 KiB) Viewed 36249 times
User avatar
FranceDidier
Administrator
Administrator
Posts: 978
Joined: Wed 26 Aug 2020 14:40
Country:
France (fr)
France

Re: Import low energy distribution (issue on longitudinal plane)

Post by FranceDidier »

Dear Fred,

The problem here is paraxality. The particles in the DST file are defined using the phase energy and not Z-Dp/p, because that is how partran works. When you import the file, the conversion is linear without taking into account the transverse divergence of the particles and considering an average energy. This is sufficient for most beams, but not in your case. You must therefore use the second type of import defined in the PlotWin documentation where the energy and phase of the particles will be used and defined.
But whatever your choice between defining a beam via E-P or Z-Dp, the 2 phase space plots will never be satisfactory at the same time, this is the limit of the current historical codes, partan works in E-P and TraceWin in Z-Dp/p.

See chapter : "Conversions between [z-z’], [z-δ] and [Δφ-ΔW] phase planes" of TraveWin manual

Regards,

Didier
FranceFred Bouly
Beginner
Beginner
Posts: 5
Joined: Tue 16 Feb 2021 13:55
Country:
France (fr)
France

Re: Import low energy distribution (issue on longitudinal plane)

Post by FranceFred Bouly »

Hello ,

Many Thanks Didier for your feedback.

I tried with the second type of import file. Indeed it remains the same for plots with Z. But Time and phase are OK.
See attached images, just FYI.

cheers,
fred
Attachments
Ascii_type2.png
Ascii_type2.png (355.06 KiB) Viewed 36241 times
Pwin_type2.png
Pwin_type2.png (431.96 KiB) Viewed 36241 times
User avatar
FranceDidier
Administrator
Administrator
Posts: 978
Joined: Wed 26 Aug 2020 14:40
Country:
France (fr)
France

Re: Import low energy distribution (issue on longitudinal plane)

Post by FranceDidier »

Dear Fred,

Could you attached your second file?
I'll have a look about it.

Regards,

Didier
User avatar
FranceDidier
Administrator
Administrator
Posts: 978
Joined: Wed 26 Aug 2020 14:40
Country:
France (fr)
France

Re: Import low energy distribution (issue on longitudinal plane)

Post by FranceDidier »

Dear Fred,

Finally, I modified PlotWin code to let the user select or not the paraxlity option when the imported file is only defined via [Z-Dp/p].

Regards,

Didier
FranceFred Bouly
Beginner
Beginner
Posts: 5
Joined: Tue 16 Feb 2021 13:55
Country:
France (fr)
France

Re: Import low energy distribution (issue on longitudinal plane)

Post by FranceFred Bouly »

Dear Didier,

Thanks a lot for adding the option.
I tested it with type 1 ascii file. The "shape" in the Z-Zp plane or Z-delta is OK, but I notice a shift (about 1 mm) in the Z position as regard to the value I put in the ascii file. see attached image.

It is still confusing for me why there is this 'Shape difference' in Z-Zp and phi-W planes, compare to the first picture I sent where I compute the particles positions with the conversions formula that are used in the Tracewin help.

I also attached both type of ascii files I used.

cheers,
fred
Attachments
type1_without_paraxiality_option.png
type1_without_paraxiality_option.png (366.55 KiB) Viewed 36223 times
distribType2.txt
(2.5 MiB) Downloaded 1726 times
distrib.txt
(405.99 KiB) Downloaded 1722 times
User avatar
FranceDidier
Administrator
Administrator
Posts: 978
Joined: Wed 26 Aug 2020 14:40
Country:
France (fr)
France

Re: Import low energy distribution (issue on longitudinal plane)

Post by FranceDidier »

Dear Fred,

Whatever file used I read Zo=-0.106 mm. Same result for dst files with ou with paraxality option for the first one.
For your second remark, I think we have to discuss.

Regards,

Didier
Post Reply